Followers

Sunday, March 17, 2019

Just mean.

I read Dr. Grumpy's blog once in awhile. He posts sporadically so I check it about once a month.
It's not usually boring. Stories about his medical practice, his kids, some history lessons.

I checked in this week and found this post. It isn't long. Go read it. And read the comments.

The condensed version is that the son of another doctor forgot his lunch, he called her for help, she refused to bring him food and to be even more supportive, called him a moron.

Some of the comments agreed with her, calling it 'tough love' and suggesting that's the way to teach 'em a lesson!

Almost as harsh as that 'mother' was with her child.

(edit) I didn't comment until after WSF left me a comment, then I combined my own answers to him and dropped them off over there. For all the good it will do.

You'd think a doctor would know a bit about child development. Kids that age, particularly boys, seem to have some difficulties with remembering to be responsible. There's actual science behind the apparent cognitive lapses, it's been awhile since I did that unit study for work, but I remember quite a bit of it. I also remember what it's like to be a young teenager. There's a great deal going on inside a person when they're that age, and it's really difficult to navigate through life for awhile.

In addition, a parent is supposed to be a support system for their child(ren). Is it inconvenient to have to bring food to your offspring? Sometimes. Should they still be supported? Always.

The message being sent to this kid is that he's not smart and further mistakes mean she likes him less. So every time he messes up, that moron remark will be in the back of his head.

Of course the doctors and lawyers of the world are supposed to be the enlightened ones, maybe the idea of compassion is for people like me.

Will the fact that he missed lunch hurt him more than the fact that his mother didn't find him worth the inconvenience of making sure he got to eat lunch? Somehow I doubt it.

7 comments:

  1. Mixed feelings on that. Prior conversations that morning? Do agree calling your child a 'moron' is irresponsible.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 7th-8th grade is my guess. Instead of making an issue and inflicting pain and a lesson on your child, how about you help him with a morning checklist? "Do you have your ____, ____, ___ and your lunch? I love you and I want you to have a great day!"

      On the other hand, if it's your goal to keep your child from bothering you for help with anything, you're on the right track there, Dr. Mom. I'm sure by the time he's in his 20's you'll rarely hear from him. And perhaps he'll call his own children morons. Who says you can't influence your kids?

      Delete
    2. Oh. And I know that some schedules wouldn't allow for this. But wouldn't it be cool to drive to the school, pick up your kid and take him out to lunch?

      I just don't have a lot of respect for someone so thoughtless. Perhaps her intentions aren't malicious at all and she thinks she's doing him a favor.

      But you know, the research is out there. A doctor should know.

      Delete
  2. This reminds me of an incident between me and my Mom not long after we moved back to the states from Japan. I didn't want to go to school - funny when I reflect on that now after subjecting myself to years and years of college, but I digress. I walked home to have lunch and she asked me what I was doing there, and to turn around and go back to school. I was so deflated. And see? I still remember it. Good times......

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. A relatively small thing from an adult perspective. But look at what it did to the child you were. I really think most parents don't mean to be hurtful to their children. I know I did many things wrong as a parent, when what I wanted was to do everything right. My heart was in the right place, but I feel bad for all the times I messed up.

      Delete
  3. My daughter forgot her lunch a few times when she was in high school. My brother told me that I should make her walk home on her lunch break and get it herself. I just brought it to her before class started. I saw no reason to make her day harder than it already was just because she forgot her lunch.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Exactly. The person who calls you for help doesn't need to be humiliated or chastised. As an adult I have had to ask for help now and then. I would be really hurt if someone were to try to make me feel bad and then not help at all.

      Delete

Would it kill you to comment?